SHOPPER REPORT APRIL 1999

 

Prepared Foods Hit Main Street

Trendy Food Appeals

Put The Blame on Candy

Blossoming Quality Wishes

Other Consumer Wishes

Scanner Errors Decline

Focus on Low-Hassle

 

 

PREPARED FOODS HIT MAIN STREET

Prepared foods have made it to the buzz level. Almost as many consumers looking as buying. Five "kinds" of prepared foods top the talk and wish lists:

  1. Really fresh prepared foods

  2. Ethnic tasting prepared foods

  3. Basic home-style prepared foods

  4. Lower fat prepared foods

  5. All-natural prepared foods

Some are happy with what they are finding. Many still aren’t finding prepared foods that match their hopes and price barriers.

POSITIVE FEEDBACK IS HAPPENING

Most of the positive feedback we’ve received on prepared food menu items has centered on traditional basics. Many traditional consumers are contemptuous of the pricey, contempory and "cutesy" dishes that dominate many prepared food sections. Those who are buying contemporary fare aren’t the ones who are complaining about it – but they are far more likely to say that it helps than to say that it’s great.

  • I really like the way many supermarkets now have prepared entrees. Chicken, BBQ ribs, beef dishes, etc., often near the salad bar. A good alternative to frozen dinners. These are great for good quick meals.

  • I'm enjoying prepared salads more and more. It's an easy way to eat healthier.

  • Supermarkets ought to stick to basic foods. Their cooks and recipes are okay for plain dishes but aren’t good enough to compete with trendy restaurants and the food shows it.

DISTRUST AND DISAPPOINTMENT
ARE STILL WIDESPREAD

  • I wish I could have confidence in the freshness or quality of prepared grocery foods – I often look but seldom buy.

  • Food left out so long it's dried up and crusty looking. Not appealing.

  • Companies are putting corn syrup in too many prepared foods.

  • Rotisserie chicken is mostly overcooked.

  • Prepared foods often have a peculiar preservative flavor so I never purchase anymore. In particular, salads.

  • Prepared foods in most grocery store deli depts. are not well "tended".

  • Would love to have calories listed on prepared fresh foods. Dominick's is the only store that attempts this, and they do it only in one section.

  • Stop trying to be "cutesy" and just cook.

  • Cook everything fresh without additives, preservatives, antibiotics and sugars.

  • At their prepared food counter the food always looks dried out and not freshly prepared.

  • At chains here in Florida, the prepared foods are disappointing.

  • Salad bars need better tending, often turn me off.

top

TRENDY FOODS AND FLAVORS

The reach of many trends is broad and rapid in today’s food marketplace. Ethnic breads and prepared foods are almost everywhere -- their popularity is reflected in the table below which shows how a cross section of trendy foods, flavors and preparations measure up on national appeal.

Lovely breads are one of the joys of the current American foodery. Thanks to taste interests sparked and nurtured by bagels, pita, croissants, tortillas and Philly Cheese Steaks (served on Italian rolls), interest in ethnic breads has spread in all directions and reached all age groups. The appeal numbers below suggest that America’s white bread culture is fading into history – except among our youngest respondents – those who are most likely to use peanut butter and white bread as their daily and/or nightly sustenance. The breads that tantalize "older" Americans’ palate and purse flourish in a jungle of textures, shapes, and flavors. It’s hard to remember how recently it was that many New Yorkers believed that there was no good bread between New York and Paris. The variety, importance and sales of fresh produce are greater than bread’s but when today’s consumers talk about what turns them on and off about competing food stores, bread is right up there.

The current appeal of prepared take-out foods is greatest for our youngest respondents but increasingly widespread among the over thirties as well. Besides the age differences, this tables shows the sophistication of the American palate. Note the wide interest in novel flavors and cuisines that until recently were triggering grimaces.

Trendy Foods and Flavors

Appeal on 1-5 Scale

(Ranked by 31-49)

Ages

19-29

Ages

31-49

Ages

50+

Ethnic breads

33%

47%

39%

Prepared take-out meals

55%

46%

33%

Provencal fresh foods

26%

34%

22%

Yam anything (sides)

32%

33%

36%

Grain based salads

22%

30%

14%

Ethnic soups/fast food

12%

30%

20%

Personal chef

20%

29%

14%

Snapper (seafood)

25%

28%

16%

Indian food (Curries)

15%

28%

8%

Pan roasted

36%

25%

21%

Tangerine flavors

34%

25%

28%

New organics in general

16%

25%

13%

Organic poultry

12%

25%

13%

Organic meats

8%

24%

18%

Organic eggs

12%

23%

16%

Adobo (spicy flavor)

22%

22%

10%

Indonesian buffet

15%

22%

7%

South American foods

9%

22%

6%

Aroma preparations

22%

21%

7%

Tropical tart (dessert)

32%

20%

25%

Pumpkin (as vegetable)

9%

16%

19%

Pre-made cereal

9%

15%

10%

Turkish-style coffee

14%

5%

3%

Caipirinha (adult drink)

5%

4%

44%

top

PUT THE BLAME ON CANDY

Depending on your age, weight, and attitude, candy is a treat, a threat, a snack, an escape, a dessert, a holiday tradition, an energy boost, or a cause of diabetes, dental decay, and overweight.

The reasons for eating (lots of!) candy vary significantly and meaningfully by age. Younger consumers use it primarily as a treat while older consumers use candy primarily for gifts and holiday traditions. Consumers 31-49 (those on the younger side of today’s middle age) use it to satisfy cravings which aren’t shared by consumers older or younger than themselves. (Some of those cravings are diet based, some attributed to giving up cigarettes, and some to the everywhere-availability which keeps temptation terribly high.

Candy consumption has been growing throughout the 90s, with consumption actually rising almost five pounds a person since 1990. Availability is a big part of the reason: candy is everywhere. Larger size packages are another part of the reason: big candy bars and pouches of candy are almost as common as Huge Gulps of soft drinks. Safe escapes are another: Hershey calls it’s new bar Sweet Escapes but considering candy’s longstanding usage as the reward for good behavior and its safety record relative to other food categories, candy is a relatively risk-free indulgence. (Flirting with a few extra calories is nothing like flirting with toxins.) Less smoking is still another part of the reason for growth: life stress is more widespread than ever and the cigarettes that helped so many of us cope with the stress have given way to treats – of which the most popular and easily available is candy!

All this considered, it’s sweet wonder Americans are getting chubbier and chubbier.

How respondents say they are using candy
varies significantly by age.

Ranked by
respondents 31-49

Ages
19-30

Ages
31-49

Ages
50+

Treat for me

4.2

4.0

3.4

Holiday tradition

3.4

3.8

4.0

Satisfy cravings

3.1

3.8

3.2

Gift

3.7

3.7

3.9

Family treat

3.3

3.6

3.3

Snack

3.3

3.1

2.8

Mood enhancer

1.8

2.7

2.1

Energy boost

1.9

2.4

1.9

Candy Quality, Taste, and Value

 

Really Yummy

Pretty Good

Total Appeal

Godiva

38%

19%

57%

Hershey

33%

35%

68%

R. Stover

21%

23%

44%

Mars

20%

23%

43%

Nestle

18%

31%

49%

Whitman’s

13%

19%

29%

Perugia

12%

13%

25%

Brach’s

7%

14%

21%

Candy-love is not without complaints as well as compliments. Many consumers see candy quality slipping and both taste and brands going down hill. Many see the gourmet candies like Godiva tasting more delicious than the popular candies they grew up with. Many complain about artificial tastes and chemical aftertastes or about freshness and declining value. About 35% think that candy is much too widely available and should be handled more responsibly or regulated out of some of the millions of in-your-face displays that create problems for those with big appetites and low resistance. Another 35% report trouble finding brands and types of candy that they especially like. Those who complain about rising costs and declining value are especially annoyed by shrinking weights and sizes that seem to misrepresent what’s in the package.

  • Godiva's quality seems to be slipping a bit.

  • Stover and Whitman's quality has gone somewhere.

  • I've bought very stale and nasty Hershey's and Nestle's.

  • Candy costs seem to have risen higher than many other products.

  • Stop making the candy bars smaller and raising the price.

  • Years ago I liked Brach's, now it is just awful.

  • I used to love Nestle's crunch and chocolate covered raisins but not good now.

  • Switzer licorice often is not fresh.

  • Godiva had live maggots!

  • Brach's is sometimes stale.

  • I used to love Nestle's crunch and chocolate covered raisins but not good now.

  • Hershey chocolate I feel has an aftertaste. I think it is the imitation vanilla.

 

Candies that many consumers have trouble finding:

  • Candies without salt for sodium restricted meals.

  • Dark chocolate.

  • Decaffeinated chocolate.

  • Godiva.

  • Gum drops.

  • Juju fruits,

  • See's.

  • Wilber Buds.


Candy wish lists are package and distribution-centered:

  • I wish they didn't have some many gum and candy machines. We have to fight the kids each time we shop.

  • Bulk departments should offer more real food and cut back on candy items.

  • I like Whitman's identifying pieces. I wish other companies would follow this packaging on assortments.

  • It would be nice to have Hershey kisses not individually wrapped. I use in large numbers when making cookies.

  • I like everything sealed in cellophane.

  • Keep it simple and portable. I shouldn't need a hacksaw to enjoy a treat.

  • Good & Plenty should be in packages, not in boxes.

  • Bags tear too easily (down the bag) after being opened.

  • Candy in plastic bags (such as Hershey kisses) should have a reusable bag.

  • Some packaging is very hard to open, especially those with a kind of foil wrapping. There should be a pull tab to open the package easier.

top

BLOOMING QUALITY WISHES

It may be the cleaner air and fresher, faster waters of spring – but consumers’ wish lists are high on quality right now. Quality hunger is popping up like Spring flowers, even in this month’s report on candy which found many consumers saying that all candy is wonderful but lots of it really should taste better than it does. The enthusiasm for up-market quality has been market-proven in coffee, beer, sauces, soups, condiments, deli meats, preserves, ice cream, produce, and breads. It’s apparent in current consumer-talk about treat-foods that are used primarily for pleasures, about foods that are used primarily for health and nutrition, and about widgets from cars to toothbrushes that really do a better job.

  • If there was more emphasis on quality, customers would accept somewhat higher prices.

  • Cake mixes make beautiful looking cakes that rise beautifully so they are used much of the time. Why can't the companies use pure ingredients? How much more could vanilla cost in place of gross tasting vanillan? 5 cents, 15 cents per box? Would it not be worth it? I cannot stand that taste so I am forced to buy bakery cakes at high prices.

  • I am very disappointed with the decreased quality of the traditional Ritz cracker as well as the poor interior packaging. I was a customer of this product for years. They’ve gotten more expensive but no longer the quality they were.

top

OTHER CONSUMER WISHES

Personal

To a generation of busy non-cooks who love to eat well, a personal cook or chef is sounding more desirable that the most fabulous kitchen equipment. The appeal of a personal chefs for entertaining and just plain living came through this month’s personal wish lists and in response to our appeal question on trendy foods and lifestyles.

Personal-chef appeal goes together with the broadened acceptance of regular eat-out and/or take-out as a good and appropriate way of life for Main Street (see Trendy Food table above) – not just something for Big City trendsetters.

  • Have someone cook my dinners at home.

  • Have a personal chef, full time.

  • Spend less time food shopping and checking out.

  • Be able to afford to eat out most nights.

  • Avoid food stores entirely.

  • For restaurant bills to be closer to grocery store bills for the week.

  • Eat everything I like and not gain weight.

  • Find out what supermarkets' mark ups are.

  • Go through the store with as little walking as possible.

  • Watch owners/CEOs shop at their own stores.

  • Talk to TV advertisers about bad commercials.

For their stores:

  • Find the store shelves stocked with more variety within brands and more brands - not just big names.

  • Have healthy kids food in the prepared section.

  • Post more rebate forms. They've almost vanished.

  • Have more in-store sampling.

  • Have more expansive salad bars at food stores.

  • Put soy milk and nut milk next to cow's milk.

  • Dispense with the extra gondolas which clutter the aisles.

  • Have a supermarket drive-through for basic staples..

  • Offer a wider variety of fresh unusual veggies at good prices.

  • Have the slicing machines in deli cleaned more frequently.

  • Have a system that pushes products to the front of the upper shelves as they get used.

  • Put help in stores that are happy that they are working and show it.

  • Have more low or no-fat muffins and other baked goods made more healthy.

  • Have a whole line of food without sugar or sweetener.

  • Have more computer interfaces in large supermarkets.


top

SCANNER ERRORS DECLINE

We asked two error questions last month:

  1. Whether our consumers thought the situation was improving and

  2. Whether they had personally experienced any errors in the last month.

To the first question, most who answered were affirmative – seeing the situation as indeed improving but often pointing out that stores really needed to keep working on it, which helps to explain the lopsided answers to the second question:

To the second question, about whether they had experienced any scanner errors in the last month, ninety-one percent of those answering said Yes, they had experienced one or more scanner errors in the last month. But the errors cited tended to be at drug stores and mass marketers rather than supermarkets, suggesting that consumers really think that supermarkets are doing better – which could mean becoming more trustworthy.

  • Yes, particularly at K-mart and CVS. Supermarkets are getting pretty accurate.

  • Several - usually discounted items.

  • Yes. I always check Safeway. Giant, Superfresh, Costco and BJ's are better.

  • Yes, at least six that I caught (I don't always check receipt or price scanned).

  • Yes, but when brought to checker's attention, pains were taken to rectify the error. They were pleasant about it.

  • Yes, most often on advertised or unadvertised sale items.

  • No but would like to report two in 1998 at SuperFresh in which I was cheated of about $10 each time because of way girl handled the coupons. Don't shop there anymore.

  • Yes, and it's always in the store's favor.

  • Too many to count!

  • Are you kidding? I watch like a hawk and find errors.

  • Yes, at the Rite-Aid drug store.

  • Yes. Scanner with the wrong amount is very frustrating.

top

FOCUS ON LOW-HASSLE

Lowering the hassle factor is the most powerful purchase driver in today’s consumer marketplace. Few marketers are successfully meeting consumers’ expectations. The comment below, from a 37 year old Mid-Westerner, is a near-perfect explanation of the low-hassle force in purchase and food decisions.

"It seems like the easier thing to do in the evening is just go out somewhere. I'm tired of the "express" line being the slowest in the market. I'm also tired of all the "deals" I have in supermarkets and fast food places. Give me a slice, some eggs, a sandwich - that's fine. Too tired in p.m. to care."

top

 

Subscriptions to The Shopper Report are available from The Consumer Network at
800/291-0100-Voice or 215/235-6967-Fax.